He Believed in Women's Rights. He Just Didn't Respect Me.

Never date a lawyer, or maybe just don’t confuse political literacy and emotional integrity.

After graduating with my undergraduate degree, I took a gap year. I spent it working a job so miserable that I quit on a random Friday after being accused of having an affair with a married coworker. It was the kind of accusation that made me wonder what kind of free time my coworkers believed me to have.

Outside of work, I was trying to build a life that looked healthier than it felt. I spent weekends drinking with people whose names I barely remember, trying to outrun a depression that followed me home every Sunday night.

And somewhere in the middle of all of it, I dated a law student.

I used to joke that he was contractually unemployed. He literally was. Law school gave him the kind of freedom where weekdays blurred into weekends, while I was dragging myself through a job that made me cry in the parking lot. Looking back, I think that joke was doing what jokes often do—making something uneven feel lighter than it was.

People warned me.

“He falls in love fast.”

“He gets bored.”

“He does this all the time.”

But every woman secretly believes she’ll be the exception. I certainly did.

Looking back, I realise I wasn’t just dating him. I was dating the idea of him. He was politically progressive. He said all the right things. He believed in equality. He voted for women’s rights. He could articulate systems of oppression, and he was a man. I mistook that for evidence of kindness.

There’s a phenomenon in psychology called moral licensing; the tendency to believe that because we’ve done something morally good, we’re permitted to behave badly elsewhere. I don’t think people do it consciously. But I think some people hide behind their politics the way others hide behind religion or philanthropy. If you can perform goodness publicly, people stop examining how you treat them privately.

For months, I couldn’t bring myself to leave him. I suspected he was lying to me. He had an unusually close friendship with a woman from law school. She was always “so excited to meet me.” He cooked for her. Drove her home from bars. I found her hair clips in his car.

Every time I voiced my discomfort, I was reassured that I had nothing to worry about. The point is that he knew I was hurting, and he chose reassurance over change. At the time, I couldn’t leave because I believed he was one of the good men. It’s funny how low that bar has become. We often define “good men” by comparison. He doesn’t catcall. He isn’t openly sexist. He believes women deserve rights. He votes in my favor. The standard is set against so much obvious harm that basic decency begins to feel extraordinary.

But a good man isn’t simply a man who doesn’t hate women. A good man protects the people he loves.

That realization didn’t come from the woman at law school. It came from one of his friends.

One afternoon, after I stood up from my chair, this friend joked that he wanted to smell where I had been sitting. Another time, he asked me which race I’d most like to have sex with. I told my boyfriend these comments made me uncomfortable.

Again and again. The jokes continued. The friendship continued. I learned something then that took me much longer to articulate. Protection isn’t only physical. It’s social. It’s emotional. It’s saying, “The woman I love shouldn’t have to keep enduring this.”

Instead, I watched him defend behavior that embarrassed me, excuse people who disrespected me, and ask me to become more comfortable instead of asking his friends to become more decent.

That is not protection. I don’t mean to single out progressive men. I share many of the same political beliefs. This isn’t an argument against the left. It’s an argument against confusing ideology with character. A man can speak eloquently about dismantling patriarchy while quietly reproducing it in his own relationships. He can advocate for women’s autonomy while dismissing the emotions of the woman sitting across from him. He can believe every woman deserves respect except the one asking him for it.

Eventually, I gathered the courage to end the relationship. It took me two days to actually say the words.

For months, I’d convinced myself that if I left, I’d never find another good man again. I wanted to preserve something—a friendship, an acquaintance, any thread connecting us—because I thought losing him meant losing proof that decent men existed.

Less than a month later, he was dating the woman I’d worried about from the beginning. Maybe nothing happened while we were together. Maybe something did. I’ll never know. I’ll never know what story he told her, either.

I hope she’s happy. I hope she’s healthy. I hope she’s living her cutest, silliest life. I know what it’s like to be a girl in love. I know what it’s like to believe you’ve found someone different.

But I’ve stopped believing that voting for my rights automatically means someone will care for my well-being. Political alignment can tell you how someone thinks about society. It tells you very little about how they’ll treat the person crying in front of them. I used to think a good man believed women deserved equality. Now I think a good man is much simpler. He protects people. Especially when the person needing protection is the woman he says he loves.

---

Photo ©  Photography of Brad Pitt & Gwyneth Paltrow